Skip to content
✖
    November 18, 2026

    What Matters Most When Choosing a New Doctor? Here's What Nextdoor Research Finds

    Nearly 9 in 10 neighbors (89%) looked for a new healthcare provider in the past year, and the most common way they found their current primary care doctor was an insurer’s provider directory (21%). Recommendations from friends and family came next at 17%, followed by online search at 14%.

    The findings come from a Nextdoor survey of 1,000 U.S. adults, fielded Nov. 2 to 5, 2026, along with Nextdoor platform data on how neighbors talk about care. The clearest pattern is in primary care: proximity starts the search and insurance decides it.

    The search for primary care

    Among neighbors who looked for a new primary care doctor, the most common reason was wanting a provider closer to home. A move or a change in insurance also sent people searching. When it came time to choose, accepting insurance led at 37%, followed by being close to home at 31% and good reviews or ratings at 25%. Cost and appointment availability each came in at 20%.

    Insurance carried the decision for other provider types too. It was the top factor for dentists at 38%, and for specialists and eye doctors at 36% each. Mental health was the exception, where telehealth availability led at 29%. What sent people looking varied: an insurance change was the main reason for a new dentist, while a new health concern was the main reason for a specialist.

    Who is searching, and for whom

    Primary care was the most common search at 48%, followed by dentists (43%), eye doctors (40%), specialists (38%) and mental health providers (25%). Neighbors searched for eye doctors at a rate 33% above the general population and for dentists 26% above.

    Many of those searches are for the whole household: 82% of neighbors are responsible for choosing healthcare providers for members of their home. Most have been with their current primary care doctor for five years or less.

    Where neighbors turn for a recommendation

    Seventy-two percent of neighbors have used Nextdoor for local healthcare information. Local doctor recommendations and nearby health events led at 34% each, followed by where to get vaccines or flu shots (30%) and local urgent care and walk-in clinics (29%). Neighbors also use it to find out whether local providers are taking new patients (24%).

    Neighbors are 36% more likely to trust a neighbor’s recommendation than an influencer’s. Nextdoor posts show the same thing. In four years of posts and comments about pediatricians, specialists, primary care doctors and eye doctors, about 6 in 10 were neighbors asking for or giving recommendations. Among Nextdoor parents, 38% have used the platform to find a pediatrician recommendation.

    Pharmacies and flu shots

    One in three neighbors switched pharmacies in the past year. Lower prescription costs were the top reason at 22%, and a move to a new area came next at 20%. When choosing a pharmacy, 62% said reliable stock of their medication is very important and 54% said the same of cost.

    Convenience shapes flu shots too. The nearest pharmacy chain was the most common place to get one this season (38%), ahead of a doctor’s office (27%). Overall, 78% of neighbors have received or plan to receive a vaccine this year, 14% above the general population.

    Care starts close to home

    People choose care close to home, and they ask the neighbors who live there. Nextdoor was built for that kind of local knowledge.

    About the data: Survey of 1,000 U.S. adults fielded Nov. 2 to 5, 2026. Platform figures draw on U.S. posts and comments on Nextdoor from November 2022 to October 2026.

    Tag(s): Insights

    Team Nextdoor

    More from the blog

    View All Posts